Monday, October 18, 2010
A scene that didn't make any sense. (Grey's Anatomy)
I hadn't watched Grey's Anatomy but some people kept saying how it's good. (Oprah among others)
Well, since I noticed last night that a re-run of an episode was on tv, I decided to watch the last fifteen minutes.
As you might know (from the picture), we were in a situation where a woman dies in a surgery, his husband blames the doctors and eventually goes on a killing spree at the hospital.
Anyway, somehow the shooter gets wounded. And isolated. (this was when I started watching the episode)
Then one of the doctors apparently gets an idea to go talk to him. Even though the doctor (as far as I know) could and should have just walked away.
This doctor's behavior is really dumb, unless he 1) wants to die or 2) wants to save the shooter. I think both are somewhat plausible and acceptable scenarios when it comes to drama.
But that's not what happens. Instead we get to hear dialogue where 1) the doctor doesn't want to die but 2) he doesn't seem to care about saving the shooter's life either.
Oh man. This doesn't look good. What is going on in here?
Then the shooter reveals that he's got only one bullet left.
Now this doctor suddenly "wakes up".
We get a really long (and not well written) speech about how he's had a good but painful life and that he's actually willing to die - OR that the shooter could kill himself and that he might this way see his wife in heaven.
First, what is the doctor doing there?
Second, his willingness to die doesn't match his behavior five minutes ago. Third, this other 'choice', "see your wife", comes totally out of nowhere and is pretty ridiculous too.
Finally, it's against hippocratic oath for a doctor to suggest committing suicide. In case someone forgot.
The doctor's rationale for what he's doing is a total mystery to me...
Anyway, the resolution is that the doctor walks away (I don't know why, if he wants to die) as the swat team is about to arrive. Off screen we hear a single shot and assume that the shooter committed suicide.
Honestly, I had no clue what was going on in here. The scene didn't make any sense to me.
Now, would the whole thing have made more sense if I had watched the complete episode? I doubt it but I sure as hell hope so.